Friday, June 13, 2014

Masters Degree Not Worth the Money? : Are Teachers Better With Higher Degrees?

Good news for the educational system and common sense in North Carolina. The basic philosophy of paying people more to become better is flawed thinking. Teaching, conveying information from one person to another is a talent that most people do not have.

When a school system has one or more of these special people, they can't be paid enough. The problem of course is most people in the teaching profession are there because they want to teach others but find it's not as easy as they thought. Just being intelligent is not enough.

In the final analysis, that certain quality that inspires learning from some people can't be bought, at any price, as this article points out, and I'm sure as we have all traveled the educational circuit pursuing higher education know this is a fact.

Is the Master's Degree Pay Bump Worth the Cost?
Source: Matthew M. Chingos, "Who Profits from the Master's Degree Pay Bump for Teachers?" Education Next, June 6, 2014.

June 11, 2014

Empirical research has repeatedly found that teachers with master's degrees are no more effective than teachers without them, yet schools continue to pay teachers more based on their advanced degrees, explains Matthew Chingos, fellow in the Brookings Institution's Brown Center on Education Policy.

Of 112 major American school districts, 96 percent pay teachers with master's degrees more than teachers with only bachelor's degrees, resulting in an average $3,205 salary difference in the first year of teaching and up to $8,411 at the high end of the salary schedule. But the impact of the pay bump varies among districts: In three Maryland districts, teachers can see a pay bump of more than $30,000 for holding master's degree.

With these incentives in place, almost half of all American teachers held a master's degree in the 2011-2012 school year. But with skyrocketing education costs, is the pay bump worth the sometimes $50,000 cost to attain the degrees?

Comparing school district salary information with the cost of a master's degree near each district, Chingos concluded that a teacher in the average school district would have to remain in his teaching position for nine years, simply to break even on the tuition cost of the degree. For teachers who plan to spend only 10 years in their field, the master's degree is likely a waste of money.

In the field of education, Chingos writes, a master's degree does not improve a teacher's effectiveness on the job. North Carolina is the first state to turn this reality into policy, doing away with the master's degree pay bump in 2013.
 

No comments: